BULLETIN 254 APRIL 1942 Management of Farm Fish Ponds By H. S. SWINGLE Fish Culturist and E. V. SMITH Associate Botanist AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATION OF THE ALABAMA POLYTECHNIC INSTITUTE M. J. FUNCHESS, Director AUBURN, ALA. Contents Page Part I--PRINCIPLES OF POND MANAGEMENT Part II-MANAGEMENT OF PONDS - 1 10 Proper Stocking for New Ponds Species Methods of stocking Sources of fish for stocking Management of Old Ponds 10 -. --------------------- 1 0 ..---.. -------------- - 1 2 --------- 1 4 14 16 16 16 17 18 19 21 ---- 21 _ 22 Fertilization of Ponds - ------------------.... Kinds and amounts of fertilizer per acre Time and frequency of application Method of applying fertilizer . .................... ..... Fishing ______. . _ Pond Weeds and Their Control _ Prevention of the establishment of weeds in new ponds Destruction of weeds in old ponds ...... Mosquito Control -- Management of Farm Fish Ponds PART I. PRINCIPLES OF POND MANAGEMENT of ponds have been built in the Southeastern States for the production of fish. Unfortunately, many of these ponds either have never given good fishing or the fishing has deteriorated within a few years. One of the main reasons for failure is the fact that most people do not understand the principles underlying the management of water areas for fish production. It is believed, therefore, that it should be helpful to review briefly some of the more important of these principles in order that the pond owner may understand more fully the problems involved in the successful management of his pond. THOUSANDS 1. The weight of fish which an unfertilized pond can support is dependent upon the fertility of the watershed. Unfertilized ponds in Alabama have been found to support from 40 to 200 pounds of fish per acre of water. The lower weight occurred in poor land areas, and the higher in the best land areas. The number of pounds of fish which can be supported in a pond depends upon the amount of food for fish which the pond can produce. The materials (nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and other elements) in the water which cause the growth of fish food are the same as those which cause the growth of field crops, such as corn and cotton. Since these materials do not occur in appreciable amounts in rain drops, they must be dissolved from the surrounding land. Many land areas in Alabama are too poor to grow good farm crops without fertilization; unfertilized ponds in these areas are also too poor to raise large crops of fish. 2. The productivity of a pond can be increased by the use of fertilizers. P'ond-fish have been found to feed mainly on microscopic water-animals, water-insects, and small fish; most of these small an imals, in turn, use microscopic plants either directly or iiidirectly for food. These plants are so small that they cannot be seen unless highly magnified; they are present in most waters but the number is usually so small that they are not noticed. When the pondI is fertilized, however, these plants grow and1 nulItilyIv so ra pidly that they cause the water to appear green or sometimes Irowxv n. Thus, the reasons for fertilizing a pond anI a p~asture are essentially the same; 1)th are fertilized to produce more plants to p~roduce more animals, hut in one case the animals are fish and in the other they are cattle or other livestock. In contrast to the low productivity of unfertilized pond,(15. p~roperlv ferttilized p~onds in Alabama support 500 to 600 p~ounds of fish per acre. (Fig. 1). WI~Upper Avei-ige size (4.0 ounces) Lower -- Avwraig e size (1.1 oUnces) in an unfertilized Both ponds wxelre stockel with 150) bluegills per acre. in a fertilized pInd. pold. 8Fish grow rapidly if they have plenty of food slowly if food is scarce. - but very W\here food1 was 1)plniflI fish in ponds at Auburn made the growth illuistrated in Figures 2 and] 8. IGU(~IRE 2. Grow~th of bluegill bream (Lrpomois ,oocrochirois Raf.). Lower -- Size (0.007 ounce) of a week-old bluegill hatched M ay I p88. Max imumtI size (6 ounces) reached when 1 year old, U pper May 1939. The extremely rapid growth of bluegills illustrated by Figure 2 is not dlesirable, however, since it indlicates that there are too few bi negill;s to utilize all of the food available. Where p~onds are adlequnately stocked with fingerlings, the bluegills should weigh 4 ounces within 1 year after stocking. The average r'ate of growth of bluegills in Alabama ponds and streams is 4 ounces in 4 years. FI(1TRE i 1.0W1 Larenm0nt h blae 1h has (Ifl,, .hm'.s riiioi 1.ac.). I,ow e Sire (0.0008 pound) of a week-old bass hatched May 1941. upper -Sire (1 pound]) reached when (6 months old, October 1A41. The extremely rap~id growth of bass illustrated by Figure3 is not desirable, since it indicates that there are not enough bass present to utilize the av ailable food. In properly stocked p~ondls, the bass should reach a weight of 1 pound -within a vear' after stocking. The average r'ate of growth of bass in Alabama p)ond1s and st reams is 1 pound in ~3 years. 4. Too many fish in a pond cause small undersized fish and poor fishing. Since a pond can support only the weight of fish for which food is available, it can suIport either a large number of very small fish or a smaller number of large fish in each acre of water (Fig. 4). The former condition results in very poor fishing; the latter gives good fishing. it is very important, therefore, to stock a new pond with the correct number of fish. 1 - I: 1 I ' I.il i 1 1;II : I ~ J I 1< I I Z l iL I_ I > Upper - Average size (4.0 ounces) 1 year after stocking with 1500 bluegills per acre. Lower - Average size (0.02 ounce) 1 year after stocking with 180,000 bluegills per acre. 5. Within one year after stocking, a pond is usually supporting close to the maximum weight of fish for which food is available. A Iter the fish used in stocking h ave spawfied once, more small fish are present than can be adejluately supported by the food1 W\hich the pond( is l)Iodtlcing. Hence, a pond( ralbidly reaches its ml]aximu0 r carryinog caplacity, usually M\thin one year. If the nu mber of fish in a pond remains the same after the first year, an in crease in the average size of these irnd(ividuals is imp lossib~le unless the food soupply is increasedl ( Vig. 5). Ada IGI(URtI 5.--Rate of gaxx th in a puod stocked w~ith 6500( bluvru1l~ ICI. acre. Abov Belova -- Averv' size (0.5 once) 63 mouiths f~ter stockin-. Avea-e size (0,9) ounce ) 2 years late.. G1. If the number of fish in a pond is reduced, the average size of those remaining increases. It' nothing is (lone to ilnrease thle food1 stl)I i0 the bondl. iceases in the size of t he fish after the first year can occur onIdv when the foo(d availabl forc each fish is increased by re01 dlicing the number of fish prlesent. i in experiment, 3 1ponds1 were origillally stocked with 6500) bluegills per acre. Two and one-half vear's later the number of fish in one pond w-as reduced to :3200 per' acre aiid in an~other to 1800 per acre. The relativ e ax erage sizes of the fish in the ponds 6 months later are sho-wn ni igure 6. hes o1 , i1 ill j ll hop 650 per acre, average wveight (0.0 0,uhce. (ie tor - :200 poeo acre, a v e r a g e weight 1.8 1:oo 0 Htttoi -a v e0 a (Iounces. per acre. w~eight 8;.7 7. Bluegill bream cannot be raised successfully in ponds containing only bluegills. Bluegill bream are excellent pond fish and should be raised in all farm ponds in the Southeastern States. However, they cannot be raised successfully alone in ponds because each pair may produce 4000 or more young fish the first year. Since they feed largely on insects and will not eat an appreciable number of their own young, the pond becomes so overcrowded with small fish that none are able to grow (Fig. 7). FIGURE 7.-Result of stocking with bluegills only. Top Average size (0.2 ounce) stocked March 1938. Average size (2.7 ounces) reached by June 1938, Center - when spawning occurred. Each pair of bream produced an average of 4000 young. Bottom - When pond was drained November 1938, the large bream weighed two-thirds as much (1.9 ounces) as in June, because the pond was overcrowded with their own young. S. Largemouth black bass should be used in ponds with bluegill bream. Since th ere is io feasible way to control the repirodluction bream, it is necessary to add some other fish to the of 1luegill 1)o0(1 to eat most of the young bream produced. The only fish wyhich has prov ed satisfactory fur this Iurpose in experiments at Auburn is the largemouth black bass (Fig. 8). This species of fish, when stocked in the proper numbers, effectively reduced the nitmbors of yoting bream and Yount, bass in Bonds so that . a c II gr( I t 11 s 11:d h~~dsj c l b Top- Average size (0.5 ounce) of bream used in stocking in June 1939, 1939. Febcoual' Center Average size of t ream (1.8 ounces) when spawn inhg occurcred. Most of the young were consume(d by the bass. Average size of iieam (1.2 ounces) Bot)tom 1939. Since the has: had reutlcel the number the bream more thn dlouibled in weight after fish produced in November of younge" fish. spawx nin. From a consideration of the above principles, it is evident that the main problems involved in raising fish in ponds are the production of food and the management of the fish population so that the correct number of animals is present to utilize efficiently the food produced. These are also the main problems involved in the production of cattle or other farm animals, and many of the principles applicable to livestock production on farms are directly applicable to fish production. Although many of the principles are the same, the actual practices by which these principles are put into operation to produce animals in water differ considerably from those used to produce animals on land. 10 PART II. MANAGEMENT OF PONDS In the following pages, detailed directions are given for the management of fish ponds. The primary purpose of such management is to produce good fishing. In order to accomplish this purpose, ponds must be stocked and managed in such a manner that the maximum number of fish will be large enough to catch; the fertility of the ponds must be increased and maintained so that a large total weight of fish can be produced per acre; pond weeds must be controlled; and the ponds must be fished adequately to remove the maximum yearly crop of fish. The control of mosquitoes is necessary to prevent the spread of mosquitoborne diseases and for the fullest enjoyment of the pond by fishermen. Proper Stocking for New Ponds In order to produce good fishing, a new pond must be stocked with the proper kinds and numbers of fish. Bluegill bream should reach a size of one-fourth pound and bass a size of threefourth to 1 pound within 1 year after stocking. If too many fish are added, 3 to 5 or more years may pass before these weights are reached. If the correct combination of species is not used, the pond may never produce good fishing. Species.-Bluegill bream (Fig. 2) should be raised in all ponds in the Southeastern States. It provides excellent sport for pole- or fly-fishing and is one of the best flavored of the freshwater fish. Occasionally bluegills weighing slightly more than 2 pounds have been caught in ponds, but such large size is exceptional. In most ponds bluegills weighing in excess of 1 pound are seldom caught, the majority varying from 3 to 8 ounces. Bluegills feed mainly upon insects which live in the water, but occasionally feed upon small fish, including their own young. When overcrowded, they will eat their own eggs, as well as those of other species of fish. Bluegills as small as one-half ounce have been known to spawn when 1 year old; where food was extremely plentiful, young bluegills weighing 2 ounces spawned when 5 months old. In Alabama, egg-laying usually begins in April or May and is continued at intervals until frost. The beds have been found in water varying from 6 inches to 12 feet in depth. Nests, varying in number from 4 or 5 to several hundred, are usually swept out side by side. The fine dirt is removed by "fanning" until small pebbles or a hard bottom are exposed. After spawning the eggs adhere to the pebbles or to the firm bottom until they hatch. Bluegills are very prolific, one pair producing from 2,000 to 10,000 or more young. Largemouth black bass (Fig. 3) should also be raised in all ponds in the Southeastern States since its presence has been found necessary to prevent a pond from becoming overcrowded with small fish. This species, often locally called "trout" or "green trout"', is usua lly considleredl one of the gamest of the fresh-water fish. It has an excel lent flavor if priop erly preplar'ed for cooking. Lar~oge specimens often h ave a strong mu sky odor and taste. This o1)jectionable taste may be largely eltim inatedl by skinning the bass andl removing the back bone and belly meat. Lartgemouth black bass weighing in excess of 10 p~ounds ate sel(loin caught in lpondls in Alabama; the majority of t ho.se caught vary ini weight from 12 ounces to 2 pmmdtils. Small bass, up to several intc hes in lengh, feed un) waterL fleas, water insects, a nd si miltar small animnals; larger bass feed main ly upon small fish, cray fish, and( frogs. Bass as small as 6 ounces h ave been known to spawn when 1 year old. Eggs are laidl in A pril, M\ay and June ini Alablamna. -Nests have been found in Nvat er' varving from 6 inches to 4 feet in dlepth. They r'esemble the nests swept out by bluegills, but are considlerably larger and do niot occur in group ]s. The cra ppie ( Fig. S)) is a som ew hat less desirabI)le slpecies, lut cani be raisedl very succ essfuIlly in ponds. This species aptparenrt ly tr'efers (lee p water, but h as been raisedl in p)onids having a maximum deplth oft 4 feet. Exceplt w hen catught on a ftlvrod or a very limberi pole, the cr'appie p~uts u1p a 1)001- light. The m eat is soft, but of goodl ftlavor. In shal1low pond(s some are caught every nonth of the year. but the peak of the ci'ap pie fishi ng, comes in the early spring. The maximum size found in tponds is betwxeeni -I and~ 5 pounds, but most of those caught xvary from 8 ounces to 1 1 plouindsI . (Tappie as small as 2 ounces have been knowni to spawni when 1 year' old. Beds have been found iii water x ar'vitg in) (Icepth from 1 to 6 feet. C atfish ate d1esir'ed byv some po1))d ownercis because theyv canl le caught easily on poles or in baited traps and wxill bite when the pond is too mu~ddy foir breamR- ot' l)ass-fish inrg. Lfart of' theiir poplarliIity is duei to the fact that they hav e relatix cly fe cx loiies and hence are easy' to eat. The flavor of those sp~ecies which call be raised in p~ond~s is geineially 'oinsidleed iinfer'ior' to that of lulegill bream ort bjass. The channel cats t Ic/lo. I's sp. ) andl the yellow or Appaluca ('at ( ilddichis. o/lrris Ki.) usually fail to reproducc in pionds andl comllpete kit bass', J aindt cotisci uettcit cannhut be r'cnrijnded('(. The yeltoxv bullhead (Fig. 10) arid the it tjtic~ etent i th lue-' i sp~eckledl cat (Alit l/ftufs ,,cl ,oo.S iwir12 ill. fo od W e.rp Ior0/ i's L es. ) ar'e the he(st suitedl for use in ponds of the species so far tested. These cats have proved less satisfactory than bluegills in farm ponds and are not ordinarily recommended. Top minnows (Ga ,nobhsia sp.) are required in most ponds in the Southeast by State Health Department regulations to assist in the control of mosquitoes. These small minnows feed upon water fleas and various aquatic insects, including mosquitoes. In the presence of floatage or weeds lying on the surface of the water, they are ineffective for the control of mosquitoes. When the surface is kept free of weeds and trash, they are of some benefit in mosquito control. Tot minnowvs are valuable for use in new ponds because they reprot h.FIGt m toE Thellow bull head (Anmcitr us wiitalis LaS.) raches a maximum size ot 2 pounds. It furnishes good fishing for 2 to 3 years in new duce ralpidly. giving birth to living young throughout the wvarm months of the year. The thousands of young p~roluced in the early spring eat insects, including mosquitoes, which would otherwise not be utilized in the )pond.As soon as the bass added to the pond become large enough, they begin to feed upon the tolp minnows, eventually eliminating all except those in the extremely shallow water. After the first summer, sufficient young bream and bass have hatched in the (ond utilize to all the food available, includ(ing the mosquitoes, aiid large numbers of top miii flows are then unnecessary. Methods of Stocking.-For best re- ponds, but eventually disap pearis from pn(onds colntainirg larcemouth bass. sults the n umbher of fish added to a pondl should actually be counteld. This can be (lone without injury to the small fish bv using a di pper and cotuitiiig the fish as they are p~ouredl into the iond. Since small fish have a tendency toi go over the spillway and to be lost, the slillway ot the iewly stocked iond should be screenied with a [uarter-inch mesh hardware screen. This screen should( exteiid about 6 inches above the normal water level ini the spil lway but shoild not reach within 1 foot of the top1) of the lam. Trash should be removed from the screen periolicalI ly and especially after raiiis. The screen may le removed after the fish used ini stockiiig have become adults; the adult fish iiormall l not go over the spillway in allreciale numhers, and so many small fish are produced that the poiid balance is not upset if some of them are lost. 13 The correct stocking rates per acre of water are given below for both fertilized and unfertilized ponds. Small unfertilized ponds, however, have proved to be unsatisfactory fish ponds in the Southeastern States because they support a relatively small number of legal-sized fish and usually become filled with weeds within a few years. A combination of bluegill bream and largemouth black bass is usually recommended, but combinations including crappie or catfish are also given for those who desire to raise these fish. Combination A. Bluegill bream and largemouth black bass.' Fertilized pond: Unfertilized pond: 1500 bream fingerlings2 added in the late summer, fall, or winter. 100 bass fingerlings added in fall or winter or 100 frya the following spring. 400 bream fingerlings added as above. 30 bass fingerlings or fry added as above. Combination B. Bluegill bream, white crappie4, and largemouth black bass. 1500 bream fingerlings added as in the previous section. 75 bass fingeringerlings or fry added as in the previous section. 25 crappie fingerlierlings or fry added at the same time that bass are added. 400 bream fingerlings added as above. 20 bass added as above. 10 crappie added as above. Fertilized pond: Unfertilized pond: Combination C. Fertilized pond: Bluegill bream, bullhead catfish5, and largemouth black bass. 1200 bream fingerlings added as in previous sections. 75 catfish fingerlings added in the fall or an equal number of fry the following spring. 100 bass added as in previous sections. 300 bream fingerlings added as above. 25 catfish added as above. 30 bass added as above. Unfertilized pond: Stocking with adult fish is not satisfactory because this method usually results in certain species becoming overcrowded while others may fail to reproduce (Fig. 11). 'Top minnows (Gambusia) should be added to all ponds in the South at the rate of 50 to 100 per acre when the ponds begin to fill. They should be secured from neighboring ponds. 2 Fingerlings are young fish more than one inch long. 3 Fry are newly hatched fish. 4 Also known as white perch. 'Bullhead catfish need not be stocked in ponds built on streams that already contain this fish. 'n. ,- Sources of fish for 1Blu e gill stocking. 'liam anti largremouith u~tk bass can b~e obtfrom slate or Icl d e ra I hatcheries; mnc hatcheries also iply crappie a it (1 I lheads or other catIt. Alabama p o nt (I Hers should ad dress it niests for' fish for )cking niew, ponds to t'e State D~epart ment of' Conserxvation, .Mont- - ttmerv, Alabama : fish a,