~9~i~-~i\01 A 'PERFORMANCE OF RYEGRASS VARIETIES IN ALABAMA 1990-91 AGRONOMY AND SOILS DEPARTMENTAL SERIES NO. 154 AUGUST 1991 ALABAMA AGRICULTURAL EXPERIMENT STATION AUBURN UNIVERSITY LOWELL T. FROBISH, DIRECTOR AUBURN UNIVERSITY, ALABAMA B t-lim M OW a r ~9~ . 1 "~ii~BB ~ *u :\ ii ~Bl~aB~P PERFORMANCE OF RYEGRASS VARIETIES IN ALABAMA, 1990-91 D.L. Thurlcw, W.C. Johnson, and K.M. Glass 1 The Alabama Ryegrass Variety Evaluation is a continuing study of available varieties and breeding lines from private companies and state agricultural experiment stations. Experiments are planted in northern, central, -and southern locations to -evaluate the varieties and lines under the different environmental conditions of Alabama. The experiments are conducted by Experiment Station personnel and the results are presented in a fair and unbiased manner. EXPRIUETAL OCEDURES AND DISCUSSION Ryegrass entries were seeded at a 20-pound-per-acre rate in rows 7 inches apart, using plots 5 x 20 feet with four replications. Good stands were obtained at the following locations: Sand Mountain Substation, Crossville; Plant Breeding Unit. Tallassee; Piedmont Substation, Camp Hill; and Gulf Coast Substation, Fairhope. The experiments were fertilized with phosphorus and potassium according to Auburn University soil test reco;mme dations. At planting, nitrogen was applied at the rate of 50 poumnds per acre, and an additional 50 pounds of N was applied per acre after each cutting. A 32- or 48-inch swath of each plot was harvested to a cutting height of 1 1/2 to 2 inches with a flail harvester each time the ryegrass reached 6-10 inches tall. A herbage sample of approximately 1 pound was taken frcm each plot at each harvest for determining forage dry matter percentage. 1 Associate Professor, Professor, and Research Technician of Agronomy and Soils. Due to dry soil conditions in fall of 1990, experiments at Fairhope, Tallassee, and Camp Hill were not planted until October 30, 25, and 31, respectively. The experiment at Crossville was planted September 20, 1990. Dry conditions at Fairhope in the fall of 1988 resulted in a poor stand for the first planting, so the experiment was replanted November 30. This late establishment resulted in no fall production. In 1989, the experiments were all planted by October 13. Above average temperatures recorded at all locations in 1990-91 caused good fall and winter growth to occur. Strategies to meet seasonal forage needs are an important consideration for livestock producers. Tables 1-7 provide yield data by harvest for one or more years at a given location. Tables 8, 9, and 10 show 3-year average yields for the ryegrass production season. A 3-year average provides a more dependable carparison of ryegrass varieties than do single-year results. ACNOWLEDGMENTS Appreciation is expressed to Mein-Huei Tzeng and Mrs. Sally Bagwell, Research Data Analysis, for the data processing of this report. Also acknowledged are the contributions of J.T. Eason and M.E. Ruf, Sand Mountain Substation; E.L. Carden, N.R. McDaniel, and M.D. Pegues, Gulf Coast Substation; J.T. Owen, Piedmont Substation; and S. P. Nightengale, Plant Breeding Unit, for growing and harvesting the experiments. Information contained herein is available to all without regardless to race, color, sex, or national origin. -4- SOURCES OF RYEGRASS SEED Beefbuilder Bulldog Concord Dalita ETOO-9-88 Florida 80 Gulf HI 124 Jackson Magnolia Marshall Multigrazer II Multigrazer II A Nutriblend OFI-AR-B7T OFI-AR-42 OFI-LM-AR-42 Rustmaster surry Tetrablend 444T3 Tetragold TX R85-2 WVPB-AR-90-1 WVPB-AR-90-300 WVPB-AR-601 WVPB-IM-AR-2 WVPB-IM-AR-F-41 Forbes Seed, Junction City, Oregon Lofts Seeds, Inc., Bound Brook, New Jersey Olsen-Fennell Seeds, Inc., Salem, Oregon Daehnfeldt, Albany, Oregon Willamette Valley Plant Breeders, Inc., Brownsville, Oregon University of Florida, Gainesville Florida Silverhill Farmer's Ass'n., Robertsdale, Alabama Van -Der -Have- Oregon, Inc., Albany, Oregon Delta and Pine Land Co., Scott, Mississippi Forbes Seed, Junction City, Oregon Delta and Pine Land Co., Scott, Mississippi Van Der Have Oregon, Inc., Albany, Oregon Van Der Have Oregon, Inc., Albany, Oregon Daehnfeldt, Albany, Oregon Olsen-Fennell Seeds, Inc., Albany, Oregon Olsen-Fennell Seeds, Inc., Albany, Oregon Olsen-Fennell Seeds, Inc., Albany, Oregon Daehnfeldt, Albany, Oregon University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida Smith Seed, Halsey, Oregon Normarc, Inc., Tangent, Oregon Texas A&M University, Overton, Texas Willamette Valley Plant Breeders, Inc., Brownsville, Oregon Willamette Valley Plant Breeders, Inc., Brownsville, Oregon Willamette Valley Plant Breeders, Inc., Brownsville, Oregon Willamette Valley Plant Breeders, Inc., Brownsville, Oregon Willamette Valley Plant Breeders, Inc., Brownsville, Oregon -5- SEASONAL DRY MATTER YIELD OF RYEGRASS VARIETIES AT THE GULF COAST SUBSTATION, FAIRHOPE, ALABAMA, 1991 BRAND-VARIETY 1/2 ACRE YIELD BY HARVEST DATE 1/23 2/18 3/11 4/10 LB.0 JLB. SEASON 5/14 TOTAL Lli~ HI 124 RUSTMASTER JACKSON OFI-LM-AR-42 MULTIGRAZER II A WVPB-LM-AR-2. BULLDOG NUTRIBLEND SURRY WVPB-LM-AR-F-41 WVPB-AR-9 0-1 WVPB-AR-90-3 00 TETRA-GOLD MARSHALL GULF FLORIDA 80 DALITA CONCORD WVPB-AR-60 1 TX R85-2 MULTIGRAZER II TETRABLEND 444T3 BEEFBUILDER MAGNOLIA OFI-AR-4 2 OFI-AR-B7T ETCO-9 -88 681 899 578 702 592 704- 830 655 674 557 498 513 499 741 598 503 819 619 659 538 526 387 588 516 419 352 586 450 609 525 440 437 478 - 514 671 507 531 436 437 403 459 703 421 500 588 412 527 488 400 383 478 373 364 368 1, 060 1,481 1,362 1,120 1,139 1,346 1,316 1,206 1,244 986 1,392 1,081 1,042 1,435 1,338 1,110 1,143 1,317 1,190 1,264 1,319 1,tv268 1,258 1,035 1,168 1,1163 1,834 1,612 1,607 1,713 1 ,671 1,666 1,583 1,528 1,639 1,540 1,658 1,548 1,545 1,826 1,o438 1, 527 1,457 1,349 1,528 1,545 11,511 1,335 1,333 1,356 1,549 1,466 1,321 2,359 2,306 2,180 2,190 2,465 2,-449 2,144 2,253 2, 151 2,020 2, 511 2,324 1,860 2,229 2,190 2,342 2,189 1,713 1,958 2,222 2,056 2,262 1,tv991 2,139 2,005 2, 199 1,808 2,484 1, 750 2,297 2,353 2,127 2, 022 1, 933 1,780 2,001 2,240 2, 002 1j, 870 2,644 1,686 1,580 1,or673 1,659 2,296 1,783 1,611 1,745 1,845 1,859 1,491 1,707 1,368 1,254 8,868 8,657 8,549 8,518 8,431 8, 425 8,350 8,203 8,jr178 8,1132 8,091 8,084 8,032 7,983 7,944 7,804 7,734 7,708 7,657 7,633 7,590 7,548 7, 422 7,238 7,088 6,917 6,500 TEST MEAN 601 478 1,218 1,544 2,167 1,891 7,899 cove(%) 32 22 15 9 9 16 7 L.S.D. (.10) 223 121 1218 163 230 356 624, PLANTED: OCTOBER 30, 1990. SOIL: MALBIS FINE SANDY LOAM. -6- TABLE 1.0 SEASONAL DRY MATTER YIELD OF RYEGRASS VARIETIES AT THE PLANT BREEDING UNIT, TALLASSEE, ALABAMA, 1991 BRAND-VARIETY -ACRE YIELD BY HARVESTDATE SEASON 1/09 2/28 3/19 4/4- 4/22 5/21 TOTAL LiL HI 124 WVPB-AR-601 WVPB-AR-90-3 00 RUSTMASTER NUTRIBLEND WVPB-LM-AR-2 OFI-AR-B7T MARSHALL OFI-LM-AR-42 DALITA BULLDOG SURRY TETRABLEND 444T3 BEEFBUILDER JACKSON WVPB-AR-9 0-1 TX R85-2 GULF WVPB-LM-AR-F-4 1 OFI-AR-4 2 FLORIDA 80 MULTIGRAZER II MULTIGRAZER II A ETCO-9 -88 TETRA-GOLD MAGNOLIA CONCORD 715 786 683 742 668 662 702 700 701 736 783 721 563 763 701 782 621 740 537 576 650 526 564 581 407 602 614 895 946 1, 039 1,04 5 853 973. 896 803 822 944 915 933 942 780 921 667 945 1,137 667 652 989 588 474 869 384 934 659 1,297 1,153 1,027 1, 24 1 1,333 1,120 1,029 966 1,122 1,227 1,040 1,116 1,073 939 1, 043 994 1, 276 1,1072 1,226 779 1,p314 915 838 1,157 752 993 937 LaL 1,281 1,142 1,018 1,187 997 10,102. 912 1,103 1,232 1,092 1j, 299 1,067 1,043 961 1 ,082 1,IF059 1,IF066 1,002 1,071 1,029 954 979 1, 047 913 928 1,007 683 LDL 2,314 1,952 1,952 1,671 1,875 1,930 1j, 957 2,290 1,681 1,771 1, 632 1,757 1j, 701 1,763 1,747 1,817 1,395 1, 292 1o,793 1,954 1,426 1j, 872 1,913 1,399 1, 850 1,1110 1,jF387 TEST MEAN 660 840 1,073 1,047 1,748 791 6,159 C.V. (t) 29 19 20 17 25 38 15 L.S.D. (.10) 227 185 -259 212 522 353 1,067 PLAANTED: OCTOBER 25, 1990. SOIL: CAHABA FINE SANDY LOAM* -7- TABLE 2.0 855 838 1,If076 710 853 771 1,027 610 834 615 704 697 892 973 684 831 753 755 697 971 543 891 888 656 976 565 698 7,357 6,jr817 6,795 6,596 6,579 6,558 6,523 6,472 6, 392 6,385 6,373 6,291 6,jr214 6,179 6,178 6,150 6,Ir056 5,998 5,991 5,961 5,876 5,771 5,575 5,297 5,211 4,978 T in AMIR 0 TABLE 3. SEASONAL DRY MATTER YIELD OF RYEGRASS VARIETIES AT THE SAND MOUNTAIN SUBSTATION, CROSSVILLE, ALABAMA, 1991 ACRE YIELD By HARVEST DATE SEASON BRAND-VARIETY 1/09 3/11 3/27 4/10 5/02 5/20 TOTAL LB. LB. LB. L L. LL LB SURRY 1,380 511 814 623 1,400 648 5,376 HI 124 1,118 440 585 787 1,647 714 5,291 TX R85-2 1,211 616 691 505 1,513 673 5,209 NUTRIBLEND 1,294 510 619 632 1,450 609 5,114 MARSHALL 957 548 712 837 1,414 639 5,107 WVPB-LM-AR-2 917 470 805 589 1,668 585 5,034 FLORIDA 80 1,196 507 791 485 1,346 679 5,004 RUSTMASTER 1,170 570 735 510 1,314 696 4,995 WVPB-AR-601 1,288 330 642 810 1,257 640 4,967 MULTIGRAZER II A 1,277 377 583 613 1,472 625 4,947 MULTIGRAZER II 1,244 267 528 717 1,300 810 4,866 DALITA 1,052 530 638 564 1,271 801 4,856 GULF 1,135 645 636 406 1,357 635 4,814 JACKSON 444 787 864 554 1,407 754 4,810 WVPB-LM-AR-F-41 1,042 343 645 678 1,282 802 4,792 TETRA-GOLD 1,042 237 489 835 1,326 736 4,665 OFI-LM-AR-42 630 652 792 537 1,376 593 4,580 MAGNOLIA 955 399 603 532 1,419 649 4,557 BULLDOG 970 515 676 486 1,333 567 4,547 CONCORD 1,224 298 428 545 1,314 679 4,488 WVPB-AR-90-1 221 683 710 679 1,504 644 4,441 WVPB-AR-90-300 369 672 734 488 1,349 585 4,197 OFI-AR-42 437 551 658 517 1,182 730 4,075 ETCO-9-88 948 308 604 458 1,075 643 4,036 TETRABLEND 444T3 747 374 625 470 1,148 575 3,939 BEEFBUILDER 671 270 551 442 1,063 644 3,641 OFI-AR-B7T 257 460 620 466 1,102 633 3,538 TEST MEAN 933 477 658 584 1,344 666 4,662 C.V. (%) 25 30 13 18 14 17 8 L.S.D. (.10) 270 169 100 122 223 136 434 PLANTED : SEPTEMBER 20, 1990. SOIL: HARTSELLS FINE SANDY LOAM. -8- TABLE 4. SEASONAL DRY MATTER YIELD OF RYEGRASS VARIETIES AT THE PIEDMONT SUBSTATION, CAMP HILL, ALABAMA, 1991 ACRE YIELD BY HARVEST DATE SEASON BRAND-VARIETY 1/15 2/12 3/22 5/08 TOTAL LB. LB. LB. LB. LB. MARSHALL 225 258 1,186 3,873 5,542 BULLDOG 302 437 1,160 3,344 5,243 SURRY 263 454 1,329 3,035 5,081 RUSTMASTER 387 404 1,067 3,199 5,057 JACKSON 221 261 958 3,476 4,916 GULF 342 386 885 3,246 4,859 NUTRIBLEND 293 287 924 3,329 4,833 DALITA 317 290 909 3,173 4,689 TETRABLEND 444T3 263 259 819 2,811 4,152 MAGNOLIA 189 295 869 2,755 4,108 MULTIGRAZER II 216 205 877 2,393 3,691 CONCORD 208 284 872 2,046 3,410 TEST MEAN 269 318 988 3,057 4,632 C.V. (%) 33 32 18 19 13 L.S.D. (.10) 107 121 215 679 731 PLANTED: OCTOBER 31, 1990. SOIL: CECIL CLAY LOAM. -9- TABLE 5. TOTAL DRY MATTER YIELD OF RYEGRASS VARIETIES, 1991, AND TWO- AND THREE-YEAR AVERAGES, GULF COAST SUBSTATION, FAIRHOPE, ALABAMA DRY MATTER/ACRE BRAND-VARIETY 1991 2-YR. AV. 3-YR. AV. (1990-1991) (1989-1991) LB. LB. LB. RUSTMASTER 8,456 8,557 7,522 JACKSON 8,130 8,340 7,428 NUTRIBLEND 8,321 8,262 7,252 GULF 7,906 7,925 7,174 SURRY 7,644 7,911 7,129 MARSHALL 8,911 8,447 7,084 MAGNOLIA 7,442 7,340 6,740 DALITA 7,915 7,825 6,480 WVPB-LM-AR-F-41 7,877 8,005 WVPB-LM-AR-2 7,582 8,004 OFI-AR-42 8,744 7,916 - TETRABLEND 444T3 7,887 7,718 MULTIGRAZER II 7,787 7,689 CONCORD 7,551 7,630 - WVPB-AR-601 7,268 7,463 - ETCO-9-88 6,928 6,714 - MONDORA 8,204 - - PENNPLOID V 8,032 - - WVPB-LM-AR-F-44 7,779 - - MULTIMO 7,654 - - EQUIPE 7,615 - - OFI-88-LM-B7T 7,590 - - TETRAGOLD 7,546 - - TETRABLEND 10 7,237 - - MULTIGRAZER I 7,124 - - LD 2810 6,783 - - LM 2881 6,701 - - -10- TABLE 6. TOTAL DRY MATTER YIELD OF RYEGRASS VARIETIES, 1991, AND TWO- AND THREE-YEAR AVERAGES, PLANT BREEDING UNIT, TALLASSEE, ALABAMA DRY MATTER/ACRE BRAND-VARIETY 1991 2-YR. AV. 3-YR. AV. (1990-1991) (1989-1991) LB. LB. LB. RUSTMASTER 8,782 7,689 6,658 MARSHALL 8,355 7,414 6,620 JACKSON 8,551 7,365 6,509 NUTRIBLEND 7,919 7,249 6,283 SURRY 8,029 7,160 6,283 GULF 8,356 7,177 6,104 MAGNOLIA 7,796 6,504 5,837 DALITA 6,399 6,392 5,429 WVPB-LM-AR-2 8,738 7,648 OFI-AR-42 8,677 7,319 TETRABLEND 444T3 8,042 7,128 WVPB-AR-601 7,162 6,990 WVPB-LM-AR-F-41 7,190 6,591 MULTIGRAZER II 6,892 6,332 - CONCORD 7,183 6,081 - ETCO-9-88 6,441 6,008 - TETRAGOLD 8,118 - - PENNPLOID V 7,969 - - WVPB-LM-AR-F- 44 7,694 - - MONDORA 7,530 - - TETRABLEND 10 7,472 - - MULTIMO 6,912 - - MULTIGRAZER I 6,720 - - OFI-88-LM-B7T 6,391 - - LM 2881 6,333 - - EQUIPE 6,324 - - LD 2810 6,261 - - -11- TABLE 7. TOTAL DRY MATTER YIELD OF RYEGRASS VARIETIES, 1991, AND TWO- AND THREE-YEAR AVERAGES, SAND MOUNTAIN SUBSTATION, CROSSVILLE, ALABAMA DRY MATTER/ACRE BRAND-VARIETY 1991 2-YR. AV. 3-YR. AV. (1990-1991) (1989-1991) LB. L. LB. MARSHALL 4,609 4,858 4,888 NUTRIBLEND 3,745 4,430 4,624 DALITA 3,714 4,285 4,615 SURRY 4,148 4,762 4,583 RUSTMASTER 4,044 4,520 4,428 JACKSON 4,084 4,447 4,400 GULF 3,674 4,244 4,098 MAGNOLIA 3,661 4,109 3,919 WVPB-LM-AR-2 4,060 4,547 MULTIGRAZER II 3,704 4,285 WVPB-AR-601 3,502 4,235 WVPB-LM-AR-F-41 3,410 4,101 OFI-AR-42 4,079 4,077 - CONCORD 3,459 3,974 - TETRABLEND 444T3 3,091 3,515 - ETCO-9-88 2,736 3,386 - MONDORA 4,257 - - MULTIMO 3,851 - - LD 2810 3,765 - - WVPB-LM-AR-F-44 3,638 - - LM 2881 3,403 - - OFI-88-LM-B7T 3,371 - - TETRAGOLD 3,343 - - EQUIPE 3,196 - - MULTIGRAZER I 3,142 - - PENNPLOID V 3,085 - - TETRABLEND 10 2,834 - - -12- TABLE 8. THREE-YEAR AVERAGE SEASONAL DISTRIBUTION OF RYEGRASS VARIETY FORAGE PRODUCTION, GULF COAST SUBSTATION, FAIRHOPE, ALABAMA, 1989-1991 BRAND-VARIETY SEASONAL FORAGE YIELD/ACRE EARLY LATE TOTAL AUTUMN WINTER SPRING SPRING LB. LB. LB. LB. L. RUSTMASTER 600 2,178 3,385 1,359 7,522 JACKSON 382 2,068 3,317 1,661 7,428 NUTRIBLEND 435 2,120 3,369 1,328 7,252 GULF 463 2,305 3,241 1,165 7,174 SURRY 537 1,849 3,208 1,535 7,129 MARSHALL 565 2,077 3,321 1,121 7,084 MAGNOLIA 507 2,049 3,063 1,121 6,740 DALITA 446 1,768 3,095 1,170 6,480 -13- TABLE 9. THREE-YEAR AVERAGE SEASONAL DISTRIBUTION OF RYEGRASS VARIETY FORAGE PRODUCTION, PLANT BREEDING UNIT, TALLASSEE, ALABAMA, 1989-1991 BRAND-VARIETY SEASONAL FORAGE YIELD/ACRE EARLY LATE TOTAL AUTUMN WINTER SPRING SPRING LB. LB. LBB. L LB. RUSTMASTER 778 1,311 3,349 1,220 6,658 MARSHALL 876 1,046 3,538 1,161 6,620 JACKSON 664. 1,19L 3,270 1,383 6,509 NUTRIBLEND 694 1,117 3,286 1,186 6,283 SURRY 743 1,191 3,123 1,226 6,283 GULF 762 1,368 2,789 1,186 6,104 MAGNOLIA 777 1,317 2,566 1,177 5,837 DALITA 572 814 3,074 968 5,429 -14- TABLE 10. THREE-YEAR AVERAGE SEASONAL DISTRIBUTION OF RYEGRASS VARIETY FORAGE PRODUCTION, SAND MOUNTAIN SUBSTATION, CROSSVILLE, ALABAMA, 1989-1991 ---------------------------------------------------------- SEASONAL FORAGE YIELD/ACRE BRAND-VARIETY EARLY LATE TOTAL AUTUMN WINTER SPRING SPRING LB. LB LB. LB. LB. MARSHALL 319 572 2,221 1,776 4,888 NUTRIBLEND 431 505 1,932 1,756 4,624 DALITA 351 241 1,933 2,091 4,615 SURRY .. 460... 564' 1,997 1,562 4,583 RUSTMASTER 390 579 1,919 1,540 4,428 JACKSON 148 637 2,029 1,585 4,400 GULF 378 683 1,661 1,375 4,098 MAGNOLIA 318 498 1,652 1,451 3,919 -15-