Project: A.I.D. csd-2270 Task Order No. 3 INTERNATIONAL CENTER FOR AQUACULTURE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT SERIES NO. 1 SEPTEMBER 1972 Progress Se. Report on Fisheries SDevelopment in Northeastern Brazil I. International Center for Aquaculture Agricultural Experiment Station AUBURN UNIVERSITY Dennis Rouse, Director Auburn, Alabama ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The author wishes to express his gratitude to all who played a role in this project. The staff at Auburn University, U.S.A.I.D. officials and, most of all, the Brazilians are all due a sincere and everlasting "muito obrigado" for everything. Progress Report on Fisheries Development in Northeastern Brazil L. Aquaculture N. B. JEFFREY' INTRODUCTION A SURVEY of fisheries problems and possibilities for de- velopment in northeastern Brazil was initiated in 1966 by an Auburn University team on a subcontract under a U.S. Bureau of Commercial Fisheries - U.S.A.I.D. contract. Personnel were E. W. Shell, E. E. Prather, and J. S. Dendy. Prelim- inary investigations were on the potential of the irrigation and water supply reservoirs constructed by DNOCS (Na- tional Department of Works Against the Droughts) to supply under management large quantities of fish for local consump- tion in this food-deficient area. The team recommended the intensive management of ponds for fish production as a productive supplement. Upon return of the team to north- eastern Brazil in 1967, a suitable area for a pond research station was located below the dam of the Pereira de Miranda Reservoir at Pentecoste. However, land at this site could not be made available. In 1968 an Auburn team consisting of E. W. Shell, E. E. Prather, and N. B. Jeffrey investigated and approved an alternate site on DNOCS lands near its Training Center. The water supply would come from the General Sampaio-Serrota Reservoir via an irrigation canal. A plan for a modern fishcultural experiment station with 40 experimental ponds was devised by E. E. Prather. Construction at this site began in early 1969 under a U.S.A.I.D.-DNOCS project with assistance by Mr. Harold Magnusson and Mr. George H. Reese, A.I.D./Brazil. Task Order 3 to Auburn University's worldwide project, A.I.D./ csd-2270, was approved and initiated November 21, 1969. Under this contract, the author began a 2-year tour in North- east Brazil with the primary duty of advising on construction of the experimental station and training DNOCS personnel in developing systems of aquaculture. At the time of his arrival, 20 experimental ponds had been largely completed except for water supply systems. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION This report is a summary of work carried out and recom- mendations made by the author during the tour of duty in Fortaleza, Ceara, Brazil. The tour began on November 21, 1969, and terminated on October 25, 1971. The scope of work as defined in the contract document was: 1. Assist the National Department of Works Against the Droughts (DNOCS), the Superintendency for the Develop- 'Formerly Assistant Professor, Department of Fisheries and Allied Aquacultures; present address: Division of Inland Fisheries, North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission, Raleigh, North Carolina. ment of the Northeast (SUDENE), and qualified organiza- tions and individuals in the private sector to program, de- velop, and implement effective methods of intensive fresh- water pond fish culture in Northeast Brazil. 2. Assist the CONVENIO/DPAN (a subdivision of DNOCS for the development of freshwater fisheries in the Northeast) in the development of its Northeast fisheries re- search program by providing technical assistance in: a. the design, construction, and operation of research demonstration facilities specifically designed for intensive freshwater pond fish culture; b. the development of freshwater fish culture research activities to provide the most effective combination of species for commercial fish culture, control of fish diseases and parasites, control of weeds, and testing of locally available fish feeds; c. the training of local technicians to assist the private sector in establishing intensive freshwater pond fish culture techniques and operations; d. the development of DNOCS research facility to par- ticipate in the comprehensive and systematic international information exchange system on fish culture techniques. The following accomplishments were achieved during the period of the contract: 1. A modem research facility consisting of 48 earthen ponds and a laboratory building was constructed. Construc- tion on the facility is continuing. 2. A research program was initially aimed at evaluating species for fish cultural potential. A total of 20 different species of fishes and shrimps was studied in the research program. 3. Brazilian counterparts were trained in basic principles of fish culture and aquacultural research techniques. 4. Contacts between Brazilian counterparts and worldwide fish cultural interests were developed through personal con- tact and literature exchange. 5. A contract proposal for development of extension ac- tivities was initiated between U.S.A.I.D./DNOCS/Auburn University, and an extension of the contract for the position of fish culture advisor was recommended. 6. The author participated as team leader and interpreter during special 10-week training tour, October to December 1971, in which four Brazilian counterparts, Jose Fernandes, Jose Bezerra, Francisco Nepomuceno, and Edmundo Duarte, visited various aquacultural and fisheries research facilities in the United States. The principal objective of this training program was for counterpart personnel to receive first-hand knowledge in areas of fishcultural research, fish hatchery management, and commercial fish farming operations. Experimental Facilities for Aquaculture hitl foold researclh fac ilts loctatedf appfroxiloatcfx ')1) kilo) i ('tels w5est of For)ltaleza, is~ pofab 'ahy the b est of its Ix ' pe ill South Anmerica. It p1 -eseotlx- conlsists of 48 eat theroi polods cloid a JIatoi to- 'lvnbildling. There('trlt 4 poiids of approi- toateix 4,600 sipiat' mett't each; 37 poids of approximit'lx :390) to 4001 squiare imeter-s each; doid 7 poo ds of appt oxiltatefx I1000 squlare n'ieters e'ach. -Illt' laltoratot\ htiltlilg 21 00 :1() toctel ) toilsists of an office, a chemilcal ,ili( tissettiol laltotatorx , a-i feed anott et 10010, a we tt lalboratorl d e 111(ightl enirs c olol) x it \ w xaY of all irrigitioli Cana1l. FIG. 3. Laboratory building and cement holding tanks at DNO( S station, FIG. 1. View Df some of the expr-ininu rronids a7 the 000(25 aquucul lural research facility. Pands in forergrournd are 350 sq meters and 'hose in background are 4,600 sq. meters. FIG 4 Crop 7 ,n7~iii C 779 sirs FIG. 2. One of te 350 sq meter ponds witn a nylon net fence to prevent escape of freshwater shrimp (Macrobrochium sp.. Research Program A total itf 21) speties (If fishets' ,id sfltilllfs xx ats stoice ttti the t exealth phase of the piogramin. Var-ioos fex t's otf fishl cuturtes xwere ex afoatetf, ft t'ftluittg nIattrl prtttducti oll, organicut and tinioI rgil it' fertiflizaltiotn, atndt feetdinIg Ill preparerd l'it iot ts In ate x itft focafls'-aix ib he miaterials. Species Research .4paiari. The ita~li li f As-f ottiotu s (clt'i'll) is at fishil thalit fas fleetn pt iwtet fot iitix xcr ('y1 hx l)OCS tattherics forI stot'ktig ill plonds andt reserv5oitrs. Thle apilajari, or osca2.1 as it is ktioxx t to thet a(fttaritlol trade, is a food ff51 iii Sooith \inet ic. It is easil , tt'ptotltctd iii pontds ill ttortheastt't Brtazil. It is a fish that hlantles wxel ,itit is l('latixe cl tasx to I Ilture. Howevtetrt. its growth frln lal l iitiaf sizte of .5 gramls to 85~ gtis itt 6 11olttfs is ref atix tkx slo\% . It is ati itmllix 1)1 is npecit's that hecom-les nollrt fpisti\oou wittt h x11 age. Produc tion of apaiat 1 i I\ un 11i vai)11s t'\erinitllI cot tdi- il~tis ait thle reseatrch fat'ifitx' is sutmtttat izet ill Tfabtlt I. Fish %\etre st ocketd at 2,8001 fer' fltctte atl ti e tIIte togtf of thle ex- petriieItt wxas 6 Iniot Is. E ath figurte reprn ('lts a tliell o (f lx 0 fpoolts. Pontdts usetdt ill tht' ('\xrimnelt wxere -350 s(Inw-lle tll('ters ill s111fte atrea. ISTBLt I. \ I I PRl UCIt fUttER 1(\ \iT HREEt tl' EX tEI'ILN I XL (;ttDtlI1('S' 5Vt11ll xx'ttgh 9('t pttoi Phl ospha~te Phoiisphtei pis' feer'r'lilr 5 28 :35.7 1,1000 5 4:3 52.3 2,25)) Net pro- (Ilitit-ot Kg. /Itca. 28 6:3 85 58.4 4,961) 1:39 Esc tht iotigth tiaitiat is at species tihat gl-oss s at a ftoodl Cr ate l ate, it pt obl)/ shotul1d be conidIeired for fi sh enitt i itt muIt i sp 1 eeies corn i/tatt/)ts teeaonse of its h ig gin rket v alute, the ease xx itit \x iie it ean b~e reproduced, antd its retsistan e to itlinit uItoig hatndlinig. Its possible role mtilit lie that of at small predla tot to) eotri iol treprodcti on of otiher species soueh ats F i/opi sp 5. or to cotro i x id ftisihes tihat eci ter t(, tused i s the pi imrt " fish lit pond( eultutte. I-osses et, thte small iitiall si/ce 5 gertants) pis tite shoriit peto ttcotf tint]W titis ftsht species \\ as te sted( prtettnte(d prtotper e\ dalttatiot of its p]itt Curintata cont. D)'\S hiatchtetries has e alstt splciel this spci e s and c prod/teed fiit t erho ttges fti- s ttekiitg lot in , vearIs. 'Ile( cuiitit coinktttt Ptltjhltls sp. ) i t5 ,tltl~ ,tttdf tiaditiottal fttod fish ill ttttttheastet t i Bazil. It is tttte ( the ttttst athtitattmt fishltit ttal catch ji! the freslis aters tif ft Not tltst. It is sli5i/edliit the IDNOCS lietic's ttstt, pit/ltitl ilieetittits. 'I'lttlt/ -1-inlata hl/~s tlittoi tts jitt atittts I atl isottcs ato 1 ilt timles t sets sttol tttgeitddx ttt itti1st\ titstt It ts prilariks at lttsx etst fish it ttli/ec pr iliiplls let tlte pl(.t pettple, bttt it is sets, platlit t l/i'eless bIectuse ti' its as at] ihbilits itttd lttxs cttst itt t elttttttt ttt sitltsxate' lisltes, tteat ati, l)'xOCS researchi leil/ts v a\is slo\x frtim attt itoitial sizew 2(0 grt nts to T:3 grtamt s itt ft ttillJ.s tisilge it stoekit g tate 1,250l pet hectare attd phmosphtate let tili/atitttt. It did itt, pellets sottetned. foTih citr , eit tit \is t I)l rem ix tt an 5 eors t fsill I ilapia. TIhe tiIltpias te stttme ttf the ttttst eliiett att(I t',tsils ectltturted pttttd fishies. Filapia tI t(I(lli (fo Itrnie Ix '. tttt /ittpltcu tt hIIas beet spilwx ed ict t t reare ltx l)OCS sittce 19.50. T his partiettlar species is herbhisvorttts. It feeds pimvarilx tt\pon the high er attjttie plantts lit tt pontdit eti S ittoltttettt. It (ftes ttot gtttsx ais t itpicdls its cdo sttnte ittl sfpecies tif tIlatpia, st ite s T. tIiltIic. The inetit xx ei gI t of tdl s tiig.-tl-thea etr 1'. r, tta//i itl e\peilink ttts stotcked ttttl5 xx itli lbtrtttt fisht \\asit ~ poxiliatelY It) gt ttts after t af-1mitil izr\Ittxilg petitt/. lThis xwais the resttlt ttf thet tt etetdotis fisht usinig it etttlit atiott of tile tilatpia itttI at piset i ti/ls sp/eci/s \\itll prttdutce lilget ts ti age si/es ttf ttlap~ia atil ai FIG. 5. iurimato (Prochiodus sp. i s the most obundant freshwater fish in northeastern Brazil where it is a popular and traditional food fish. Curitnatt pilco. The cutrim atit piit ( Pto 'Itil//I/I sp. Iis ersv sttttilllt ill its eilttaetet isties tti tite ct/Iitnitta c//irIum. bi-ot it dttcs t tts tti% to Itt iget size. Recseatrcht re(stults iticate tha~t xx l/ this fish xx\as sttiekec att 6i25 pc'r teetilrc' and cixxitit get attis tti 214 gtrins itt 8.5 tttottis. 'lie ct ti ilti tt paeui is p1 tiiathl scuitablc fit 5/ tow I initedl fisit cui t/tid opetra)'t~ti/ilns. Its t e~tii ~ aec'epfiti/ii]its it tile to itt kets oIt the Nthteatst comn~ii ed x itli its fatit g-r/ixxl tit t rc'l ,ttix els loss stttekintg rte~ts mtghldt itntdica~te its possible use its it talittor species itt Ilit i speci('s cottlibittltittl s. It its bee'n spawn ted unde/rc i/,tc'~eli ti/looitimtis ttsiit ho/t'rmone~ itijcti/ils. FIG. 6. Titopio rendo/i, formerly T rrte/onoptesrro. These fish were part ot the commercial catch from General Sompolo Reservoir. hiv e st fttal e pied atotIs ottI ce prtopcer stock ittg trates tof tia pia~ antd thtc predttor species cati Ibc est ablfishI ed. ExperIi- mtentts shltttd illsoi bte ettttc tee t/t test tile tI/ctiit/re ( (hit/la oct ffl( y) t .Is it p) 'iedittt i species xxi t / tilaipia. (11 tt. oetitlit atittt t is summ ar~izedI it T ale 2. Both spc'es \e stockcet att 560t pe hectare, i :ttt(lc letiietli tif ti/c cx- Itt it/tel tt \\a 1t88 (has s. I\ ('l\is /INSI t/ I rcatmtiie I k(1 fish. NO ttt~ll Kg. /tt. 170) 300t Pt 2.5 16 7001f) -1.76 krJv 6.sitiontt iv'rttts'r to, prou/s// Pf t'Ilit such its '. ItIa il l tic' [i//ptcl, 7tt rutt / (' i s itt a I onie rc'sersvotir. Also, it servc's its at spc'cic's SSic i/t llI c-/it/et It is tccmitmenc'dced/ thatt ttis spces I/c li/et d lot" stocdk- ill',' ill the lar gel resevxNi (Ill ~Iits it IlIIII!! s[pecies ill ((imo TIra ira. [This predaciu l ei (~CC Ii I, dw iniaalaaii 1 XX idelv (listihtlile tllililigiii irt1 I wist e! i i Br~azil. ItI XX ideX used~ tlitil f IX b tile [)irel. peopl~e oIt the i egiili hilt iX ]lit ph te!! i'd species Ibel.iiile of its laige 111lliIIei of ill tialiliiieliilii hiiiie. Thle tiairia epi odlici ll philds iiii lit I I fllilIctill oII tifapiai (a 1W tll i s fromI!(il 7 gi ala i tot '[lie( tra!!diX is pr aI)IX not a X \er , good~l sp~eciCX t fish (Ill- til I IIXXC e it i pesenit ill the XX ate!s ot the rcilili a loiof ill deX elilfillig etelisjX I'iliethodii( fih eiltiiieC. Its pllXsifi(i IX l it peielil 111isel.olblaiol hudk FIG ' , - - - 1- - 111 freshwater fish in northeastern Brazil. . 0 1, 11 FIG. 7. Trairal floptias ntaoaricus), an endemic predacious fish that is distributed throucghout northeastern Brazil. This species may be effecive incnrlig ec 6 numbers of sn ill ticpn fir ponds 7Al FIG. 8. Tucunore pinimo Cichia tmensis) an the left and tucunaore comumn C. ocellaris) an the right. Peseacla. T]111 peseilI I ( / 1 iwgsil NIllX((1 1(11 .X l ,iillN IX isI iloi~t II ih tiiaf [IXits h beeiIi oiICCd fIX the i)NO(S ilatehli ciliX f1)1 IllitiX X \ 'l X er. This fish [i C iI-cwioiI iiit tfeedX lislilli 1)11iliXiIX tel Xrail1. tce i I XtIN liillioll 11111 '111od grIXXti rate. Tilt [){'X.ail does 1 )X siii lnat!!! Ili poiii(tX floiXX LX C it isX e XCI difficlit to hlim this sp,~cel fisli eiii1tii i )i ipztIilXs. It is XClIX sensitiveC til iiiiaiiges ill Becausit XXe of Iits IC~ poo h n li1 1 tj (Iit ie t iii the f l i t o I iths'ltlld )i ll.lC e li tlls , iX s Ilisl willr X liiC Ili Tilll\I i it Ilafe l. iie. TheX I X l Cld \ill) i X holill iflIs. isC iltiof lit(F (itile riK h iriiiti.dSo FaleXorvrSS FIG. 10. Mandlube (Aegeniosus brevififis). This catfish was spawned far the first time in captivity using pituitary, harmane injections. Stirttlbim. ThIisX speiesC (h PwiltpO/!y.Xtoma~ X. IX i 11 o ito XXhere1 it iX aiX lilillC. ExperIimenI~itX ill (oibIlliltll XX itil Xize' of its Illililthl it \X abXle toilljihilati' hilIot oft thie III i.(illtii , 1 ul0r - . 41L - broodil Stock. I IIt tilc t it \ka, loo Ittit i i tlts a pi odiittol I()] efft (ill ish i 11i FIG. i -,ii i tPsr opiorystur p , si , of the large piscivorous catfishes Occurtrincj in the major rivers. \Iaiidi. liiitiidtti ( I'Pilildio Iuaiii.x ) ix oitt of tI li IMIiliei toiitx th ttt speciex til catfixshes. It ix all exce'llet food fiih, ctituipat lug fax -t .li xx iih the tilittei catfishi gi.roxx ixst, but thisxx axil l-i d tix btcausxe of piotlemst xx itli Tisx fixsi doesl~ tittixtime i9119tti iatitil (Ijiite \%il eiatici il) l)*it Sfto lie it xpectex thait is liilti tot iilir x (1-lig t hll- tIilttg. It ifite hav\e shiarp is iiiiex xx iitl cauxe xttii pi lt It is t 5 eittitiiiced thlt aitidjtiiol eliolt ble placedi iii xftdx- ill(,x t x 'liaidi Exx ts it oul ci]tiiii t i titit tl xxi]] ut flit Illii f ii ( 1(\ pi wi t d r Ixiiitililh I i l m ld if xf 1 1i i tr r FIG. 12. Mandi tensive culture systems (alrati. Tlis fishi / I i i~ mii ,~ j) , itii If Il xiiler petciex itf cattihex. Iii rxperimlenlts it gi exx x(i itixx i it pi epatei ratiton. Thei xpecies cait hi teptitiicti it) eaiptix it\ tixitig pittlitit xv ilifeetiotix. FIG. 13. Well dlevelop , oo ar es of ria l llu- ttit \%\1 itis fish. 1 rii jtu li. T timlt) tj l l X ctjl ft dr s)iI i is tite of tiit iarget citrii i fron lti thet \tia i/ il itti It is rete d to itachla iniii itiiin sizt oft 25 kilo tiaits. It is alsoi all e\(eilttti tood fih III itix 1969, 11)11 t\tiii tch 25 spectittictis X Otin tetd 1w INO(S T)heti iteiwe st iz i oinx iii-a %\-it 19 Trix ()it Martch 1, 19 1,j the ix uilo \Ngexeigilit \\dxtiits toi- to ielx a3l ii. inicxatd posbities tit it su (ital Lxic gultt ltoxx tot it 1 iititiicet tis fixst ill itixi dx y. )ie treproidutionti ,.~ FIG 14 irsiroty b.iolgist Air-ry it-- D,, i tntborqu Myletes brdensl, a large churocin from the Amazon River Basin. This fish reaches a size of over 3 kilograms in 2 years. Pirapitixiga. Thle pi iapltli.a. t1lttossoioi sp.) iIs ailso ooc1 of the lim1 el tlillill" 1i 101 theAliatl Bili/Iilsiii. ft is I-c p~ortedi to reath it iiiimin~i size of 5) kifiigiai ati1 hi~ lis tlelo~lstlritec ectellentf 1411155tl. A slii 1 )Iltlt of 4ff sfpec mels. s6t it Ia l I 55ejtlt of 2ff (Ti.ills. ii liv C oil juiii 6, (I 970. )it \Iiti cl 1, 1971. thei as eio- ii4(5eight \\ is mole tlliio I kilo'llilii. l1liiis, ill 9 Ilootlis the fish (T1ic\\ to 111011 thanl I fbilqu fill 111id ij 1 If 1( i Trlopicail. th'lese fishes are biiii ised toit .1stitabf!i' sue foi reproducflltionl ISo thati 1151)( d iiitioli fietss (C the ft\\(i species imlle~l T. hrolint 11 h X felliiie T. fiiltottice1 till Ible attii) puished. This ciross is repor11tedl t(1 prloduce I 0ff per tcent 11ialce It is i (i.11iliniiICd thiat it great delca of (11111 be plfacedf ill cllilif Sc tet'sio of iti liiil llls aul ex (otic spies tot iheifiici the mo1st iffhiiiiit iiolfbilittiols of fishies fiii pondi~ It otr iii their acttC 1 )filijf ol flcal irkcts ill 11111 fieast- II tllililil11a S the fiifts o tllo\ fii.w iiltls specties appefatr stilt ,ibl lotmore iotni~cecnh lil~loi rlp Mtl A FIG. 15. Pirapitingo Mylossome sp. is another largo, chotacin tram the Amazon River Basin. Piall 5 erduideiro. HIrood( stock ot this sfpeties I/(L ) ills I1. Ik iiilii4 1411)5511 at thei I)NOCS reseairci faiilst flotlfi- tihi icseacii. \o alctul tesclit \,ssas tfoll ssit ilik lsp 1 ctics 11111111 this cotiliiatt piod.1( Hesiclic 191101ts ss itli this sfpecies shouI(Ith e i liied at es iflatii 14 Os irole 5as i pssib le iliolfilsk toiN tiott agt if)II tiulnitllioli fish ti11ftilles ll 1 d its lfflciellu\ lit foodi iltl iiiiioll Exotic species. Spetlilieis ot tur speies oIf tlltit fishes - ais's (,Hp (CO iiophflwtiotol, 1111 sie ils li) (Ill/- pollai~llili/lll llllItris) Tila ll00( Oi ctil 1iii I. /ittt lil lle 9111114 14111551 ftoi, lesialt i stuiels. Thie alass talf pI sf~ctloiilis I a ill the si l il al p 6 sfpetil)i is I scII ohtiioit 29, I 91. Thitst fish i t bioi gitissii ats fbtoodh stock so that ill f it it ill C I ficef sp1a55 ili \\145ill [iI tS it 5 lilli1 fih 1()l HG 1 F-s-turshiinip (Macrobrachium was aptued i Serota Reservoir. FIG. 16. Gross corp Ctenophoryngodon idella) is o promising species for fish culture and aquatic wieed control. Thei t\%0o species of tflalpia \%r( ic 5tlit to the l)OS hroli \fliil I)s \f-. 1. Hardi of thie Ccitie CTedliIlic Vtltstj( I 8 cries This large male Pit". Tlie jpitii ( AiIacrobhiu /iiil lrc/itis is a i t ft esfi- %\autei slIlllip Axxtrts otf iil~trtst. Cultuie ttctfilies for the Jpitidfitiilli of' 115 tiii(5os a fittli tdes eoptt ill FlIritla I lasaii, aiiii ttlitiis ill Asia fior itfated species. 'fhe pitu is frest~ti il liiimitetd lililihwill s om ii 01)9 s (Ills oIf ft Notrth- east. Feiialt sfietinis xx itfi (141s 55919 af capre 1111111 Set- I tta ilestli 1, iii the eggs ssc~ C l siihsjiitit httthetd. The laps ile rtliliif ittI ilivefiflrIol ifs8 (las s orI less. Fioi slIrSisal ttf thle fitS if slil ill)) safii itY mo1(st rloiili ahose 10f pp.t. After 1-iticlii the jus eiie stagt ilies iiati toi freshw5attrs all& 4 where they grow to maturity. Successful culture for this species will depend upon the development of suitable fa- cilities near supplies of fresh and salt water so that the critical water quality conditions required by the young larvae can be maintained. DNOCS should consider the development of a larval raising facility near Fortaleza for the production of postlarval shrimp. This species has potential for culture in the Northeast. One other area that might be investigated is the stocking of pitu in many of the reservoirs that do not have sizable populations of the pitu because of lack of ac- cess for the young shrimp that hatched in the downstream brackishwater areas of the rivers. Research on Feeds To obtain the higher productions in fish culture, it is nec- essary to use prepared rations. To evaluate the possibilities of prepared rations, a pelleting machine for experimental ra- tions was ordered. This machine is now being used to pro- duce experimental rations. Staff of the International Center for Aquaculture provided valuable assistance in analyzing samples of locally available agricultural products and in ad- vising on the formulation of the rations . An excellent report, "Racoes para Piscicultural Intensiva No Nordeste Do Brasil," prepared by Paiva, Freitas, Tavares, and Magnusson, is a summary of the research done in the preparation of rations by DNOCS. The recommendations made in this report should serve as a guide for the prepara- tion of rations for use in Brazil. Efforts should continue to be made to develop suitable rations for fish cultures, but major emphasis should be placed on the utilization of organic fertilizers. Because of the high costs of the agricultural products required for rations and the traditionally low market value for freshwater fish prod- ucts, intensive fish culture systems for the near future cannot be based upon feeding prepared rations. Systems that use organic fertilizers such as manure from pigs, chickens, and ducks seem most appropriate for the present. Counterpart Training The Brazilians who worked with this project included the entire staff of the Convenio-DPAN at one time or the other (12 to 15 persons). However, the actual technical staff as- signed to fish culture included only 3 Brazilians, one of which is also an administrator. With the support of AID Brazil, one of these, Amaury da Silva received 9 months training in fish culture techniques at Auburn University. Two other biologists, Helio Melo and Odilo Dourado, re- ceived training in related fishery fields of limnology and fisheries biology. Also, four Brazilian biologists took part in a special 2-month training tour of various fish hatchery, aquaculture, and fisheries research stations in the United States. This group, with Dr. Jeffrey acting as coordinator and interpreter, visited the following facilities: 1. Oct. 22, 1972 2. Oct. 26 3. Oct. 27 Eastern Fish Disease Laboratory U.S. Department of Interior Bureau of Sports Fisheries and Wildlife Kearneysville, West Virginia Pisgah Forest Fish Hatchery U.S. Department of Interior Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife Pisgah ForestLN-orth Carolina North Carolina State Fish Hatchery Marion, North Carolina 4. Nov. 1 School of Marine and Atmospheric Sciences University of Miami Miami, Florida 5. Nov. 2-3 Tropical Atlantic Biological Laboratory National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration National Marine Fisheries Service Miami, Florida 6. Nov. 4-5 7. Nov. 8 8. Nov. 9-10 9. Nov. 11-12 10. Nov. 15 11. Nov. 16 12. Nov. 17 13. Nov. 18-19 14. Nov. 22-30 15. Dec. 6-9 16. Dec. 10-11 Biological Laboratory National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration National Marine Fisheries Service St. Petersburg, Florida Marine Resources Laboratory Alabama Department of Conservation Dauphin Island, Alabama School of Forestry and Wildlife Louisiana State University Baton Rouge, Louisiana Biological Laboratory National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration National Marine Fisheries Service Galveston, Texas Department of Wildlife Sciences Texas A & M University College Station, Texas Warm Water Fish Culture Research Laboratory U.S. Department of Interior Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife Stuttgart, Arkansas Kelso Exploratory Fishing and Gear Research Base National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration National Marine Fisheries Service Kelso, Arkansas Department of Wildlife and Fisheries Mississippi State University State College, Mississippi Department of Fisheries and Allied Aquacultures Auburn University Auburn, Alabama Southeastern Fish Culture Laboratory U.S. Department of Interior Bureau of Sports Fisheries and Wildlife Marion, Alabama Department of Zoology Southern Illinois University Carbondale, Illinois Formal academic and research training programs for per- sons in fish culture should be initiated and have been rec- ommended for future contracts. The ultimate success of this entire program will depend on the ability of the Brazilian Nationals to carry out the program without outside technical aid, and it is to this end that the program objectives should be directed. During the 23 months of this contract, the Brazilian tech- nical staff working with fish culture became familiar with many general techniques in carrying out the research pro- gram and to some extent with the general principles under- lying aquaculture. Continued technical assistance should in- crease their rate of development of suitable pond culture methods for Brazil. RECOMMENDATIONS Facilities. Construction of more ponds utilizing the avail- able land should continue. Sufficient resources to complete construction of approximately 100 ponds of 1,000 square meters each should be sought. This number should be adequate to furnish the facilities necessary for the compre- hensive research and production program. The present fa- cility with 48 ponds and the laboratory is the largest in South America. An all-out effort should be made by DNOCS, U.S.A.I.D., and Auburn University to complete development of this facility and to assure its continued participation in the overall fisheries program of not only northeastern Brazil but the rest of South America. It is recommended that DNOCS establish a permanent annual budget for proper maintenance of this research facility. Research. The philosophy behind the first 2-year program was one of training and preparation for the future. It was deemed most important for the overall program to train the Brazilian Nationals in principles and methods of fish cultural research for development of culture systems. Many species of fish were used at different levels of culture. This has served to make the Brazilian biologists more knowledgeable of the many possibilities available to them. The program now has at its disposal brood stock of numerous native and exotic species of fish from which to select suitable species for fish culture systems. In the author's opinion, emphasis should be placed on some of the exotics, such as the tilapias and grass carp, for which culture systems already exist. How- ever, such species as the tambaqui, mandi, and pirapitinga should remain an integral part of the research program. These and other endemic species could contribute signifi- cantly to a successful fish culture program. Attempts should also be made to secure other species such as the filter feeding catfish, madara (Hypothalemus edentatas), from the Amazon Basin. This fish could have worldwide impact as a cultured species. Counterpart Training. The DNOCS scientists are capable persons who would benefit greatly by additional training in fisheries. Scholarships should be made available to furnish specific advanced degree programs in fish culture. The Brazilians are aware of the potential the program has for them and the future of fish culture. Technical assistanc. from U.S.A.I.D. should probably continue for a period of at least 5 years. At the end of this time, the Brazilians will have the necessary facilities and should be adequately trained to carry out a comprehensive program that will greatly benefit not only Brazil but other countries as well. 10